Opinion: Los Angeles supervisors fake it in closing public out
September 28, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
An editorial in the Los Angeles Times argues there few reasonable justifications for the Los Angeles County supervisors to hold discussions with Gov. Jerry Brown behind closed doors on the impending shift of inmates and parolees to local control. In discussing policy concerning the shift, the supervisors claimed they had to meet privately to confer [...]
California: Alleged open meeting violation by Upland City Council
September 26, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
A former City Council candidate has filed a complaint with the San Bernardino County District Attorney alleging that the council had committed two open meeting violations. The first was not reporting an action taken during a closed session and the second concerned a resolution to create a supplemental retirement plan. -db From the Inland Valley [...]
San Diego health care district accused of open meeting violation
September 26, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Tri-City Healthcare District board has been accused of violating the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law, by holding a closed door session on strategic directions for the district before convening again in closed session to evaluate the performance of their CEO. Critics said the session on setting strategic directions should have been on an [...]
California: Orange County D.A. drops open meeting charges against school district
September 22, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
After a preliminary finding in May that the Capistrano Unified School District violated the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law, the Orange County District Attorney’s office announced this week that they could not corroborate the finding. But the office found a lot to fault, using colorful language to criticize the way the district conducted meetings. [...]
Opinion: Congress should pass law requiring budget supercommittee to conduct open sessions
September 15, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion
An editorial in the Beaumont Texas Enterprise argues that the Congressional supercommittee to find $1.5 trillion to cut from the federal budget should conduct its deliberations in public. Some legislators and sponsoring a bill requiring the committee to hold open hearings and disclose any contacts members of the committee make with lobbyists. That latter requirement [...]
Republicans call for open meetings for supercommittee on budget cuts
September 13, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion
A group of Senate Republicans wants the Congressional supercommittee formed to make $1.5 trillion in cuts to the budget open to the public. The Republicans not only favor admitting the press and public but also live streaming of the proceedings. In its first meeting, the subcommittee voted to allow some closed meetings but pledged to [...]
Willows: California Attorney General slated to investigate alleged open meeting violations
September 13, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
With local authorities hamstrung by conflict of interest and lack of resources, California’s state attorney general office may step up to investigate alleged open meeting violations by the Willows City Council during a June 14 closed meeting. The council has been accused of discussing items not on the agenda and the budget in a closed [...]
No violation of open meeting act by Santa Barbara City College says district attorney’s office
September 8, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Santa Barbara District Attorney’s Office informed backers of the outgoing Santa Barbara City College president that the college Board of Trustees had not violated the Brown Act, California’s open meetings law, by not disclosing the outcome of Superintendent-President Andreea Serban’s evaluation. The backers of the former president are seeking to recall three of the [...]
Open meetings: City council barred from taking private tour of water facility
September 1, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
California’s Attorney General Kamala Harris demonstrated the long reach of the state’s open meeting law, the Brown Act, in her opinion that for majority of a Southern California city council to take an invitation-only tour of a Northern California water district facility would be a violation of the law. Harris also said that even if [...]
California: DA enforces state open meeting law concerning Novato affordable housing project
August 29, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Marin County district attorney told the Novato City Council they had to remedy an alleged open meeting violation by holding a repeat of its review of an affordable housing project. The new meeting was held August 23. California’s Brown Act, the open meeting law, requires public agencies to post their agendas at least 72 [...]
California: Judge dismisses open meeting lawsuit against Capistrano schools
August 29, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
Schools watchdog Jim Reardon lost his suit against the Capistrano Unified School District when a judge ruled the district properly dealt with an alleged viiolation of California’s Brown Act, the open meeting law. After Reardon challenged the district over a March closed door meeting to partially restore pay cuts to employees, the district met again [...]
Big Brother emerges in guise of Ohio congressman
August 25, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, News & Opinion, News Gathering
Republican Congressman Steve Chabot of Ohio didn’t like his chances of avoiding an embarrassing Youtube video from going viral on the internet so he did what a self-interested politician might do. He enlisted the police to confiscate cameras from citizens attending a townhall meeting. The only trouble is that he now has to contend with [...]
California: Dispute about what Capistrano schools must do to rectify open meeting violation
August 25, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
Sam Capistrano resident Jim Reardon sued the Capistrano Unified School District in March claiming the board held a closed door meeting to partially restore teacher salaries and failed to report their actions. Without acknowledging a violation of the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law, the board subsequently held a public meeting to discuss teacher salaries, [...]
California: Two board members leave closed session fearing violation of open meeting law
August 23, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
Two board members for Salinas Valley Memorial Healthcare bolted from a closed door meeting fearing that the panel had violated the Brown Act, California’s open meeting act. One of the two requested a legal review of the issue during the meeting and left when he was not happy with the response. An anonymous source said [...]
Policy makers for California courts make changes to improve transparency
August 22, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The administrative body for California’s courts has taken steps to improve accountability and transparency by opening key meetings and increasing the time for public comment. The changes came after judges and others criticized the courts for not being open to dissent and for its secretiveness. California Newspaper Publishers Association’s Jim Ewert said, “I think it’s [...]
California: Chico school loses charter partly from alleged open meeting violations
August 22, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Chico Green School lost its charter and state funding partly because the school allegedly violated the Brown Act, California’s open meetings law. The attorney for the Green School said the Brown Act did not apply to charter schools since the act did not mention them. The judge who withdrew the state funding said charter [...]
California: Too quick may mean open meeting violation by Sacramento City Council
August 19, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Sacramento City Council may have violated the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law, when it quickly adopted a plan for Sacramento redistricting at its August 9 meeting, writes Melissa Corker for the Sacramento Press. Corker says the council suddenly presented a new map for redistricting after months of work by a citizens’ advisory committee [...]
California: District Attorney cuffs Novato City Council for open meeting violation
August 18, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News
The Marin County District Attorney criticized the Novato City Council for deciding at the last minute to discuss an issue without informing the public. The issue concerned affordable housing, of great interest to the public. The council agreed to readdress the matter at a future meeting. -db From the Marin Independent Journal, August 16, 2011 [...]
California: Oakland transportation agency reconsiders move to San Francisco after alleged open meeting violation
August 18, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, News & Opinion
The Metropolitan Transportation Commission voted to reconsider a decision to move from Oakland to San Francisco after critics alleged they violated the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law, in approving the move. The commission is now considering a site in Oakland along with the San Francisco site. -db From KGO-TV, August 17, 2011, by Laura [...]
California: Redding City Council faulted on open meetings
August 8, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
A watchdog group has alleged that the Redding City Council violated the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law, by not reporting on decisions made during a closed session on July 19. The Marking a Difference for Shasta group said the council failed to report decisions on an electric utility lawsuit and a civic center lease. [...]
California: Atascadero City Council stops responding to public during open comment session
August 4, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Atascadero City Council has decided without public notice or discussion to halt give-and-take during the public comment session of council meetings, says David Broadwater, a local activist. In an opinion piece in the Cal Coast News, Broadwater writes, “Previously, under the Brown Act, in response to questions and matters raised regarding non-agenda issues, the [...]
California: Menifee city council drops ‘secret ballot’ in selecting new council member
July 28, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
After opinions that a secret ballot could not be used in appointing a new member to the Menifee City Council, the council revised the plan. Under the new plan, council members will give each candidate a ranking which will be displayed to the public. The rankings will be tabulated to select the new member. The [...]
California: Publisher says boycott of St. Helena Star retaliation for criticism of council
July 28, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, Freedom of Speech / Press, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
Doug Ernst, the publisher of the St. Helena Star says an e-mail circulating in town calling for a boycott of his newspaper is in response to a news story and an opinion column written in the aftermath of a district attorney report that found the city council had committed five violations of the Brown Act, [...]
California: Critics claim San Luis Obispo City Council violating open meeting law
July 28, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, Access to Records, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
Critics in the San Luis Obispo community are alleging that the city council is regularly committing open meeting violations including sending an e-mail to fellow council members to generate support for an issue before the issue was listed on an agenda. When the president of the police officer’s association asked that the e-mail be made [...]
New York: Group seeks to overturn same-sex marriage law with open meetings suit
July 26, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News
New Yorkers for Constitutional Freedoms has filed suit in New York claiming the state’s Open Meetings Law was violated in passing the law giving gays the right to marry. Among other things the group claims the Republicans met in secret to discuss the law. The challenge is not expected to succeed at least on one [...]
California: Alleged Santa Ana open meeting violation
July 22, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Santa Ana City Council failed to comply with the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law when they did not allow the public to comment on issues disclose in a closed door meeting on July 18. They also changed the location of the closed door meeting without notifying the public. -db From a commentary in [...]
California: Glendale councilman claims council violated open meetings law
July 17, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
Glendale city councilman Rafi Manoukian has alleged that the council violated the Brown Act, the state’s open meeting law, when they held a closed meeting on the topic of the city manager’s impending retirement. Although Manoukian would not say what his allegation entailed, the closed session on the city manager was posted as “Performance Evaluation [...]
California: Allegations that Santa Barbara City College trustees violated open meeting law
July 17, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
An activist group that opposes four recently elected trustees of the Santa Barbara College Board alleged that the board violated the Brown Act, California’s open meeting act. The group is charging that in evaluating the Superintendent-President Andreea Serban, the board failed to disclose the results of her evaluation. The group is pressing for a satisfactory [...]
California: Calaveras County school board accused of open meeting violation
July 13, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Grizzly of Big Bear is alleging that the Bear Valley Unified School district board of trustees violated the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law by inviting a citizen to a closed meeting. The district superintendent said the woman was asked to testify in closed session on a confidential matter that required secrecy. Jim Ewert [...]
California: Napa District attorney says St. Helena council violated open meeting law
July 7, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Napa County District Attorney is holding the St. Helena City Council accountable for observing the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law. He said it was no excuse that the council violated numerous sections of the law after receiving incorrect legal advice. According to the D.A. in discussing the performance of the city manager, the [...]
California: Santa Barbara City Council restricts open meeting law
June 9, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Santa Barbara City Council, citing the need for freer discussion of issues, voted 4-3 to roll back aspects of the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law. The council majority expressed the need for more leeway in discussion before making decisions and argued it was unproductive to restrict private meetings. The mayor who voted against [...]
San Francisco supervisors provoke questions about open meeting violations as set to approve demolition of rental homes
June 7, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
Writing in the online newsaper, Beyond Chron, Dean Preston alleges that the San Francisco Board of Supervisors made back room decisions on a project to demolish 1500 rental homes without allowing for public comment. He said one supervisor negotiated 14 pages of amendments to an agreement with the developers while the full board refused to [...]
Editorial: Decision on Santa Monica jet flights not revealed in accordance with open meeting act
June 6, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Santa Monica Daily Press is alleging that the Santa Monica City Council failed to inform the public of an important decision not to pursue a lawsuit after a federal court had stopped the city from enforcing a ban on certain categories of jets at Santa Monica airport. The city council made the decision in [...]
California: Novato man alleges freight contract process violated open meetings law
June 2, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
Expressing his own opinion, Bernard Meyers, former Novato councilman and current board member of the North Coast Rail Authority (NCRA), has alleged that NCRA made a deal with Northwestern Pacific Co. (NPC) to lease a freight run without proper public notice and participation. Meyers describes the alleged violation, “NCRA’s activities — interviewing the bidders, choosing [...]
Editorial alleges Bay Area Rapid Transit violating open meeting law with subcommittes
May 31, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
A Contra Costa Times editorial alleges that Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) is violating the Brown Act, California’s open meeting law, by establishing 20 subcommittees that meet behind closed doors. BART claims they are only advisory committees, but the editorial argues that even so they violate the spirit and letter of the law. The editorial [...]
California: Open meeting law ignored in demolition of historic Ross schoolhouse
May 29, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
A cherished landmark, the one-room school house in Ross, California, was destroyed without public input sometime in 2007. Hidden from public view on the Ross Common, no one noticed until this year that the century-old building was no longer there. Town officials have found no records showing that the issue was ever placed on a [...]
The secret’s out: transit system needs to come clean
May 26, 2011 by Dick Rogers
Filed under 1st Amendment News
The Bay Area Rapid Transit District, in response to charges of “secrecy and bureaucracy run amok,” has promised to reverse a years-long practice of holding closed meetings about the public’s business. After a blistering editorial by the Contra Costa Times, the district’s board of directors acknowledged that as many as 20 committees have met privately [...]
California: Winters school district trustees alleged to have violated open meeting law
May 24, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The Yolo County Grand Jury reported that the Winters Joint Unified School District board of trustees violated California’s open meeting law, the Brown Act, by failing to properly place an important personnel item on the agenda. The report was released a little over a year after the board fired a popular principal at Winters High [...]
California: St. Helena newspaper holding city council to account on open meeting issues
May 19, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
The St. Helena Star is alleging that the St. Helena City Council has once again violated California’s open meeting law, the Brown Act, by not posting their discussion of compensation for former City Manager, Mary Neilan. The council held a closed door meeting to discuss Neilan’s no-cause firing and negotiated a severance package and confidentiality [...]
California: Citizen alleges open meeting violation by Menlo Park school trustees
May 16, 2011 by donal brown
Filed under 1st Amendment News, Access to Meetings, News & Opinion, Sunshine Ordinances
A local open meeting watchdog, Peter Carpenter, accused the Menlo Park School District of violating California’s open meeting law, the Brown Act, when it used secret ballots to rank candidates for the superintendent’s job. Carpenter demanded that the district nullify its choice of superintendent and allow the public to discuss its short list of candidates. [...]









